gategrrl

I honestly don't see how people who are/were soooo up in arms about Sam/Jack ship, think that this is soooo wonderful in comparison. Does it really matter if the two actors play into it and have some chemistry? Hate to tell'em, but I thought RDA and AT had chemistry (the real thing) in the early days of the series, before it was fucked up with "ship" and longing looks and sappy eyes and comments.

I see no difference between the two. V/D and J/S, that is. They're all on their respective teams. They shouldn't be "dating" or screwing or romancing each other.

Talk about being hypocritical.

From:

It might just be Daniel taking Vala off the base, now that she's totally acclimated and proved herself trustworthy and essential to the SGC, with no romance involved. Id est, people might be able to fanwank it that way.

I agree about the ships, for the record. I won't say that I don't think the actors have chemistry and it shows. And the entire cast had non-romantic chemistry from the beginning. There was never a reason to push the romance angle. Ever.

From:

crazymadjo.livejournal.com

Hmmmm. I actually like Vala, and thus far haven't seen any ship - but really don't want to. Not now that she's part of the SGC. I hope this episode just turns out to be a "just friends" sort of thing.

From:

Yeah, I read that in the spoilers a long time ago. I had hoped... Actually, I hadn't really hoped anything. *g* I've tried not to think about it. I guess if I hoped anything it was that this season wouldn't play out the way it has so far, but I dread this episode now more than ever.

Is this also the one where Mitchell comes riding in on his motorcycle to save her? And/or where they get chained to a bed together?

From:

Even if it's "just friends" I don't think I'll like it. I don't want Daniel to be "friends" with Vala.

From:

New spinoff:

Stargate Hijinks With Vala!

From:

seanchaidh.livejournal.com

Okay, that sounds lame and pointless.

From:

It does. It's the set-up to get Vala off the base. Although why it couldn't have been a TEAM effort, you know, with the TEAM, which is what so many people keep claiming they WANT to see, well, yeah, it IS pointless. Unless you're a V/D shipper.

Yes, although I'm not drinking champagne, and clicking my heels, and having a party, yes, I can say I'm glad the show appears to be finishing off in its current incarnation, although the news of a set of movies isn't thrilling like it would have, if Vala weren't there.

From:

I get in a dither when I go to OS and the Spoiler thread for an episode is just awash with Vala/Daniel shippiness, I could throw up. I don't remember the Sam/Jack shippiness being allowed to overtake a spoiler thread like that. Whatever happened to NONship coverage on a thread?

Yeah, guess I'll have to cut back on my visits there.

Thank god shows like Medium are coming back, and Harry Dresden is coming up. And yeah, I know HD is coming onto SciFi. And you know what? WTFcares?

From:

In the clip that's going around, apparently there's more Daniel-lipservice about how wonderful Vala is, etc etc and vomitous. You know. More "She is SOOO GREAT!" talk.

From:

Where is the clip? I haven't seen it.

From:

LOL I shouldn't laugh, though. It sounds like that's exactly what they have planned.

From:

Sue listed it up on the OS thread for this episode this afternoon. She may have listed it on her LJ by now, I'm not sure.

From:

I'm probably banned for life there now, anyway. Remind me not to go there even if I get an email saying that someone has replied to something I wrote.

Unfortunately for me, the two other shows I really like, Boston Legal and Supernatural, both might be icky this season, too. The last episode of Boston Legal almost sort of sucked and I hated the new character they introduced. They won me over with all the new characters at the beginning of season 2, and then they all disappeared except one.

SPOILERS (For people on your flist who may not want to know ): On Supernatural, they're bringing in an "instant family": a mother figure who apparently knew their father, but whom they've never met (and who hugs them and they call her for advice) and a beautiful young girl who's also a kick-ass hunter (she hits one of the brothers and then is supposed to have "sexual chemistry" with him). UGH!

And on Degrassi, my other show, my favorite character left because his actor is going off to college. He'll still be on the show sometimes, I guess. *g*

The upcoming TV season isn't looking that appealing to me, but hopefully it'll all be better than it sounds and better than SG-1.

From:

Okay, thanks.

From:

Aiz, I just edited my original comment to include the clip location URL. Try that.

From:

This is why I don't go in those threads. People who ship are going to see it a certain way and I don't like having that tainted view going in. I had a lot of episodes ruined because I was influenced by the Sam/Jack hate. It's no one's fault but my own, but I probably wouldn't have seen ship in some places if I hadn't been looking for it. That doesn't work for everyone but I'm blind like that.

For the record, I haven't seen any Daniel/Vala ship this season. I like being in my little world.

From:

Well, I'm not going to bother to watch this clip until I see it in the episode. Like I said before, I haven't seen any ship yet and I don't plan on getting excited over something that I can easily read as friendship or Daniel being nice.

I am more troubled over the fact that this is going to be an obvious plot device and that they are using Daniel to tell us how wonderful she is. The writers seem to have a long history of believing this is the way to sell a character. I haven't liked it each time they've done it.

I'm just going to wait and see.

From:

I haven't seen any ship either. But then again, I don't tend to see some of the worst of it unless people point it out to me. (I like being in denial.)

I'm just going to take a wait and see attitude. I can't get all riled over this show anymore. Things are bad enough right now without me adding onto it ;)

From:

Oh, thank you! I just found it and was going to make a post with it, too. hehe I want to horrify anyone on my flist who isn't already on yours. Actually, though, most people on my flist love Daniel/Vala or at least don't mind it.

That clip is horrific, isn't it? EEEeee!

From:

Well, I certainly learned my lesson. As long as there are oodles of squeeeling shippers and Vala-lovers over on OS, I am going to have to limit my exposure to the chatroom. sighs

And you're right, I think: I'm trying to detach myself from this show, but honestly, it's like watching your exboyfriend derailing in a train wreck, and it's hard to not feel involved somehow, even if you hated how he turned out after several years of dating him. I suppose the only real way to turn off the show, is to turn off the fandom completely as well.

From:

I think it comes down to what you define as fandom, too. I only discuss the show in certain places and with certain people. It might seem odd or maybe even contradictory, but I don't feel like I've left the fandom. I've cut down my exposure like you wouldn't believe (you'd never believe it when I gripe the way I do). I limit myself to a few areas. I'm happier this way. I just can't get worked up about a TV show anymore. I may still be enjoying it in a superfiscal way and I may mourn what greatness has been lost, but either way I can't invest myself that deeply. It's negatively affecting my life. None of us need that on top of everything else we have going on.

And as sad as it is, many of us have somethign to fall back on now. Whether for you its Dresden Files or SBG and Aiz have Supernatural. I'm working on my own writing. We have something to fall back on. It makes me really sad. But I'm also happy that I've been able to get to know people in the fandom and that I believe the show has had a great run, for the most part. I'm excited for movies, even if I am cautiously optimistic about them. But in between the shipper wars and the flaming, it's been nice ;)

In the end, fandom is what you define it to be. So, if that is a forum, a community, a list, a group, your LJ, or even just a few people, it's still your own terms. Of course, if it means not watching the show or interacting with people, that's your choice too. What works for one person isn't going to work for another. But you know that.

From:

*plus fingers in her ears*

Lalalalalalala

I'm going to ignore this and hope I forget this conversation by the time the episode airs.

From:

hehe I was just kidding. I'll post anything behind a cut, and I didn't have any commentary on it except "barf." *g* You might actually like it or at least not mind it.

From:

I never saw Jack/Sam ship, either, until Evolution and Lost City, but then once I saw it, I saw it everywhere--or at least the attempt to shoehorn it in, even in season 1. *g* It has nothing to do with what anyone else said, but my own stupid brain, and it ruined almost the whole show for me now. *g*

I'm not necessarily seeing Daniel/Vala ship on the show, but I don't even like their friendly moments. I don't want them to be friends. I can't believe in this Daniel. I'm disliking him more and more with every episode.

From:

And it's quite a trick when a new character can make you dislike one that you've liked for years, eh?

Yeah, I don't for one second believe that Daniel would open his arms in welcome and praise to Vala like that, no matter how forgiving he was. She took too much away from him. And he's not the same niave "boy" he was in the first season with Shyla. I thought he knew better.

From:

That's where we differ. I don't mind them as friends because I think that Daniel geniunely tries to see the good in people and he's trying with Vala. Mind you, I don't agree on how TPTB have rushed this on the audience to the point the characters are waxing poetic about her, but historically Daniel is one to try to be compassionate. And since TPTB have "softened" Vala, then it makes sense for him to have softened his stance on her. For me, it would be highly out of character for Daniel to continue to hate her.

From:

To me, Vala's progression to pussy-cat just doesn't ring true.

From:

That's what is annoying me the most. I feel like TPTB wrote themselves into a corner. I tend to look at everything from a storytelling pov, and for me, they introduced her as a sassy sexy thief. (Mind you, I also didn't like PU.) She was selfish to the core. Then, they brought her back part time and realized they needed to do something more with her character so they kept her as a selfish thief, but with a softer underbelly. Then, as a regualr, they knew that wouldn't fly, so they changed her into this really nice mommy who wants to winover her demon spawn child.

This progression is so choppy and illogical that it makes my brain hurt. You cannot have your cake and eat it too.

However, I can handle Daniel a lot better this year than last year. This year, he feels more like Daniel to me. I'll never get the Daniel I want back, but the Daniel that I saw last year (with Vala) is not a character I want to watch. This year, he's got some of that spark and compassion back and I like that. But that is as far as I can go with it really. I watch the show on a surface level. And I think that is the honest reason I can give Vala some leeway this year. But I can only speak for myself.

Overall, it really does speak to poor quality in writing.

From:

And it's quite a trick when a new character can make you dislike one that you've liked for years, eh?

Yes! I'm disliking Daniel's reaction to Vala, much more than I dislike Vala herself. I actually dislike how everyone is reacting to her.

From:

I don't buy the softening of the character at all. One of the things that made Daniel's interaction with Vala in the past was that he wasn't fooled by her at all, and now it's like he's totally snowed. I can't stand to watch it, and yet I can't look away.

I think it's highly out of Daniel's character to be so totally taken in by someone like Vala, after having learned his lessons with her the hard way--again and again and again.

I don't think Daniel ever hated her, though. I just don't think he should trust her at all or be her friend in that way.

From:

Then, as a regualr, they knew that wouldn't fly, so they changed her into this really nice mommy who wants to winover her demon spawn child.

This progression is so choppy and illogical that it makes my brain hurt. You cannot have your cake and eat it too.

Exactly! And it drives me nuts. *g* It doesn't ring true, thus I don't buy it, and I don't think Daniel should either. Why wouldn't it have worked if they'd kept her as a selfish thief with a softer underbelly?

Also, I just don't get that Vala wants to win over her child. She seems very cold and ambivalent towards Adria. Daniel seems to care more about her than Vala does. Even so, they both seem very mild about it all. I get an extremely "ho-hum" feeling from them both. I don't really even get what they're trying to go for.

However, I can handle Daniel a lot better this year than last year. This year, he feels more like Daniel to me.

I feel exactly the opposite. *g* I feel like he's not anywhere close to being Daniel any more. In season 9, I felt it was a logical progression of the character, but this? I hate it.

but the Daniel that I saw last year (with Vala) is not a character I want to watch.

I didn't really want to see more of that at all, and would probably be complaining just as loud if they'd done that, because I didn't like that Daniel either except--I felt he was being the real Daniel. I still liked him and felt he was completely justified in his reactions to Vala. I just wanted him back so we didn't have to see Daniel so manic all the time.

But as far as Vala goes, if we had seen some logical progression with her character, I think I'd have been able to accept it better. Now it's just:

She's changed. She's good now.

How has she changed?

It doesn't matter. She says she's changed and everyone treats her as though she's changed, so she has changed. Also, Daniel says she's changed, and now even Bra'tack says she's changed. There you have it. She's changed.

This show actually succeeded in making me hate Bra'tac. *g* I never thought that would be possible.

From:

suebsg9.livejournal.com

I see it as exactly Daniel does as two co workers going off base and having dinner; Vala of course would see more since its Daniel takeing her out. For me as any one that has fallen for Daniel since Shar'e has died I never see anything serious. Daniel is just being Daniel; the dinner is his way of thanking her for proving him right into joining SG1.

But then I am into seeing this two as friends and nothing else.

sue

From:

That little scene is EVERY bit as shippy as any moments the J/S shippers squeed to death over. More, actually.

I'm still throwing up.

From:

EXACTLY. After a scene like that, couldn't you just HEAR the Sam/Jack shippers saying how that validates their ship beyond any sort of denial by nonshippers?

This is so beyond the type of scene they had Jack and Sam play - it's undeniably shippy to me, considering the sort of crap the PTB used to foist off as Jack and Sam scenes.

I find it VERY hard to see it as a nonship scene. And I still want to put my finger down my throat and throw up.

From:

I'm not sure I really care if the J/S shippers use it to validate anything.

I'm more bothered that people who would have screamed to holy hell if that scene were between J and S will probably see that as purely platonic, not an ounce of ship in sight, just because they like Vala and adore Daniel.

Sorry, but it doesn't work that way for me. Ship is ship, and this ship is no less tolerable than J/S ever was. In some ways, I find it more repugnant.

From:

That's what I meant, SBG, I didn't say it very clearly. My brain is scattered today.

From:

Nah. You've said it several other places in the thread, and we're clearly in agreement. ;)

It boggles my mind, frankly, that people can react so differently to two very similar situations.

From:

Well, apparently my style is too confrontational for OS at the moment (which may or may not be true). I'm not trying to turn anyone around from their Vala-adoration, etc. But my attitude needs adjusting so that I can be calm, cool and collected before posting what I *feel* so I don't upset anyone or make them feel like I'm attacking them.

I guess if you like Daniel and Vala together, you're feelings are so much more likely to get hurt than another type of shipper. But perhaps I'm wrong.

From: