gategrrl ([personal profile] gategrrl) wrote2008-02-14 10:00 am
Entry tags:

Dog Memoirs - the newest subgenre

Okay, perhaps as a subgenre, it really isn't THAT new. After all, fictional dog stories have been around forever, since before Anubis or Cerebus poked their heads out of the collective human imagination.

I was in Target this morning, gathering Valentines Day treats and cards for the kids, the Guy, and one of the kids' classes, and wandered over to the book section. And I was amazed at the number of Dog Memoir books that were on the shelf. It's not as apparent to me in a Barnes and Noble because of the size of the store. But at Target? Wow. I counted at least nine books with dogs on the covers. They varied in focus from the dog being the main focus, or the dog being a featured part of someone's life, but still, more or less as part of their life. 

It's an interesting phenomenon. After all, I don't see reams of books centered on pet cats, lolling on their owner's laps and uplifting their lives. Could just be the nature of the beast (so to speak). Most of the books I've skimmed through center on the life, and then eventual death, of the family's dog, going into great detail of the grief process, and how the dog affected not only their, but other's lives, through their very existence.

I suppose Dog Memoir books help their readers get through or remember their OWN dog experiences, and the sadness of their pet's passing. Heck, I was tearing up at the description of the after effects of one memoir dog's death. It brought back the death of my own favorite dog. He died over twenty years ago. Did his life fit within the formula I see in these books? (after all, how different can all these dogs' lives be, except for their owners' lives?)  Most likely, yeah, his life did. Is it enough to write a memoir about? I've no idea. 

What about you? And your pets? Could you write a succesfull memoir featuring them?

Are their other subgenres that you know about, that others might not have realized are out there? Speak out!
ext_3440: (Default)

[identity profile] tejas.livejournal.com 2008-02-14 06:38 pm (UTC)(link)
After reading the James Herriot books a million years ago, I can do without having my heart ripped out by pet memoirs. ;-)

I've considered writing something from one of my cats' perspectives, but it would likely have a very narrow appeal.

"Waited on top of fridge until the primate woke up. Announced my desire for beef.

Announced it more loudly.

Heard primate cursing at one of the lesser pride members.

Reminded primate that her goddess required her presence.

Settled back down on top of the fridge while primate wallowed in her inferior bath.

Growled at Doofus. He didn't notice. Next time I'll shove him in front of the idiot canine next door.

Primate finally arrived. I rubbed against her wet fur in retaliation. If she'd stop rinsing off my mark, I wouldn't have to keep marking her. Damn primates. They're useful, but not terribly bright.

Still don't have my morning beef."

See? Kinda narrow appeal there. :-)

[identity profile] planet-mel.livejournal.com 2008-02-14 10:44 pm (UTC)(link)
There are just as many if not more books featuring cats. They just might not be best sellers right now. The Cat and Curmudgeon series... the Cat Who Went (Wherever) series. Not to mention that sub-genre of mysteries: cats who solve or help solve crimes. The Cat Who mystery series has been going on since 1969!
I spent 10+ years working in various retail bookstores. There are more sub-genres than you think.
Vampire Romances, Lesbian Lit, Hard Science scifi, Cosy mysteries, ...

[identity profile] gategrrl.livejournal.com 2008-02-14 10:57 pm (UTC)(link)
Hey there - long time!

I guess I should have been more specific - I was talking nonfiction, really: there ARE tons of cat-based mystery series (and I've seen cat based romance series, too).

But I haven't seen too many Memoir Cats on the shelves.

[identity profile] planet-mel.livejournal.com 2008-02-15 05:34 am (UTC)(link)
Both the Cat and the Curmudgeon and the Cat Who Travled To series are non-fiction. And, they are memoirs about the cats as much as their owners.

[identity profile] gategrrl.livejournal.com 2008-02-15 08:06 am (UTC)(link)
Ah, sorry!

[identity profile] khek.livejournal.com 2008-02-15 12:38 am (UTC)(link)
I bet it's because "Marley and Me" did so well a couple years ago. I think it was on the bestseller list for months--last fall, they even released a "juvenile edition" of the book (where they basically just cut all the references to sex) and a picture book version for really little kids.

Those publishers have to try to corner that market, y'know.

[identity profile] jennywren102.livejournal.com 2008-02-17 04:38 am (UTC)(link)
I'll admit I've been enjoying some of Jon Katz' dog books borrowed from Mom. And yes, I probably could write a memoir. It just wouldn't be nearly as good as his (of course, he's a writer by profession and I'm a lowly Domestic Engineer).

My pet memoir would go all the way back to my childhood and mention how the dogs and cats and other critters in our fold affected me. There have been so many. The years spent without a pet in my life were notable *because* of that absence and the feeling of being incomplete without one.

Have I mentioned that we currently have nine cats? And I love each and every one for their uniqueness.